Alasdair Gray’s novel is deeply entrenched in the cultural landscape of Glasgow, Scotland. As a celebrated artist and writer hailing from Glasgow, Gray infused his work with the essence of the city. However, while the narrative of the book unfolds amidst the streets, landmarks, and authentic locales of Glasgow, the film takes a daring artistic departure by reimagining the story within the fantastical backdrop of London, Paris, a ship, Alexandria and Lisbon. Glasgow is entirely omitted from the movie, and none of the main cast members are Scottish.

Despite the book being narrated from Archibald McCandless’ perspective, the movie immerses viewers in Bella Baxter’s journey as she matures. Certain scenes feature a small round frame that offers glimpses into Bella’s evolving perspective and developing brain.

One of the film’s most significant contributions to Gray’s novel lies in its cinematography. Yorgos Lanthimos and Robbie Ryan employ unconventional angles, fish-eye lenses, and transitions between monochrome and color. This visual distortion serves as a replacement for the novel’s unreliable narration, adding a fresh layer of intrigue.

Although the changes in setting and perspective are significant, both the book and film coincide in exploring themes of challenging the established systems of class, gender, and imperialism through Bella’s unique perspective.

Poor Things (2023) Movie poster and book cover compared.

Poor Things

Yorgos Lanthimos, 2023

VS3

Poor Things
Alasdair Gray, 1992

Poor Things is a movie directed by Yorgos Lanthimos in 2023 and based on the book of the same name by Alasdair Gray, first published in 1992. The movie features Emma Stone, Margaret Qualley, Willem Dafoe, Mark Ruffalo, Christopher Abbott, Charlie Hiscock, and others.

What users say

“The movie is better than the book”

No recommendations yet.

Watch & Read

Get movie and book on Amazon

RATING

8.4

/ 10

Movie Poster: Poor Things (Yorgos Lanthimos, 2023)

8.1

/ 10

Book Cover: Poor Things (Alasdair Gray, 1992)

*Note: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

AUTHORS' QUOTES

“Poor Things is a great book, but a challenging and complicated one. I love it, but in order to transform it into a film it takes a lot of trial and error, there are things you have to reinvent for it to work on screen.”

YORGOS LANTHIMOS, Director

“A large part of the novel is about socialism. Our version is always more focused on Bella’s journey. But in her journey she comes up against all these structures in society.”

YORGOS LANTHIMOS, Director

“I’ve seen Dogtooth and I think Yorgos is a very talanted young man.”

ALASDAIR GRAY, Book Author


Storyline

Witness the extraordinary story and remarkable transformation of Bella Baxter, a young woman who is revived from the dead by the brilliant and unconventional scientist, Dr. Godwin Baxter. Prepare to be captivated by this incredible journey of Bella’s resurrection and subsequent evolution.

Movie vs Book

movie vs book

Key differences

• The movie is set in a surreal version of London instead of Glasgow
• While the book doesn’t specify a particular era, the movie appears to be set in the 19th century
• The tone of the film is lighter, balancing humor with darker themes
• The book has a more intricate and chaotic storytelling style
• In the book, the character of Bella Baxter is more ambiguous
• The ending differ in the book and the film and the film introduces a new character

Portraits of Bella Baxter and Bella Caledonia, the book character


Comparison

Alasdair Gray’s novel is deeply entrenched in the cultural landscape of Glasgow, Scotland. As a celebrated artist and writer hailing from Glasgow, Gray infused his work with the essence of the city. However, while the narrative of the book unfolds amidst the streets, landmarks, and authentic locales of Glasgow, the film takes a daring artistic departure by reimagining the story within the fantastical backdrop of London, Paris, a ship, Alexandria and Lisbon. Glasgow is entirely omitted from the movie, and none of the main cast members are Scottish.

Despite the book being narrated from Archibald McCandless’ perspective, the movie immerses viewers in Bella Baxter’s journey as she matures. Certain scenes feature a small round frame that offers glimpses into Bella’s evolving perspective and developing brain.

One of the film’s most significant contributions to Gray’s novel lies in its cinematography. Yorgos Lanthimos and Robbie Ryan employ unconventional angles, fish-eye lenses, and transitions between monochrome and color. This visual distortion serves as a replacement for the novel’s unreliable narration, adding a fresh layer of intrigue.

Although the changes in setting and perspective are significant, both the book and film coincide in exploring themes of challenging the established systems of class, gender, and imperialism through Bella’s unique perspective.


Poster of Poor Things, the 2023 movie by Yorgos Lanthimos

Year

2023

Minutes

141

Movie Rate

8.40

Source: IMDb

Cover of Poor Things, the 1992 book by Alasdair Gray

Year

1992

Pages

336

Book Rate

8.10

S: Goodreads

Book

Poor Things

Country: UK

First published in: 1992

Length: 336 pages

Genre: Fiction

*Provided by Amazon

User polls & recommendations

Which is better?

Poster of Poor Things, the 2023 movie by Yorgos Lanthimos

Movie

0

%

2 VOTES

*You can vote only
once in this poll.

Cover of Poor Things, the 1992 book by Alasdair Gray

Book

0

%

0 VOTES

*You can vote only
once in this poll.

movie

IS IT WORTH WATCHING?

Poster of Poor Things, the 2023 movie by Yorgos Lanthimos

WATCH

Yes

0

%

0% No

1 votes

0 votes

book

IS IT WORTH READING?

Cover of Poor Things, the 1992 book by Alasdair Gray

READ

0

%

0 votes

0 votes

0 votes

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LISTS AND GROUPS

Related Lists

SubjectEmma Stone

Emma Stone has captivated wide audiences with her charismatic performances across a diverse range of films.

Check out all the movies and TV series coming out on week 50 and find out the readings that inspired them.

AwardsOscar Nominations 2024

All the movies nominated for the 2024 Academy Awards that are based on or inspired by books.

AwardsAdapted Screenplay

All the movies that have been nominated for Best Adapted Screenplay Academy Award since the first ceremony in 1928.