Shutter Island provides an immersive psychological thriller, filled with suspense that captivates readers throughout. Its 2010 film adaptation offers a comparably thrilling experience while staying true to the original story. With its abundance of cryptic clues, unexpected twists, and disturbing revelations, the narrative prompts readers to question assumptions and closely examine each element.

One notable contrast between the two versions is the portrayal of the institute and the island itself, which appear more expansive and imposing in the film. While the book suggests a relatively small island, evoking a sense of claustrophobia for readers, the movie still captures the eerie ambiance established by Lehane’s vivid descriptions. The landscape and buildings in the film almost embody character-like qualities. Another significant difference lies in DiCaprio’s portrayal of Laeddis, evoking sympathy from viewers compared to the more malevolent depiction in the book.

The film’s conclusion is significantly more ambiguous compared to the book. While the overall storyline unfolds similarly, the film’s ending introduces uncertainty. As Laeddis converses with his doctor (revealed to be Chuck), he poses the question, “Would you rather live as a monster, or die as a hero?” This leaves the audience questioning whether he is feigning a relapse in order to seek the tranquility of ignorance that a lobotomy would provide.

Shutter Island (2010) Movie poster and book cover compared.

Shutter Island

Martin Scorsese, 2010

VS3

Shutter Island
Dennis Lehane, 2003

Shutter Island is a movie directed by Martin Scorsese in 2010 and based on the book of the same name by Dennis Lehane, first published in 2003. The movie features Leonardo DiCaprio, Emily Mortimer, Mark Ruffalo, Ben Kingsley, Max von Sydow, Michelle Williams, and others.

What users say

“The movie is better than the book”

But the book is worth reading.

Watch & Read

Get movie and book on Amazon

RATING

8.2

/ 10

Movie Poster: Shutter Island (Martin Scorsese, 2010)

8.1

/ 10

Book Cover: Shutter Island (Dennis Lehane, 2003)

*Note: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

AUDIOBOOK

Audiobook cover of Shutter Island, the 2003 book by Dennis Lehane.

Shutter Island

Read by: Tom Stechschulte

Storyline

Marshals Edward ‘Teddy’ Daniels and his new partner Chuck Aule travel to the Ashecliffe Hospital for the criminally insane on Castle Island in Boston Harbor. Lead psychiatrist John Cawley refuses to turn over records, and they learn that Solando’s doctor Lester Sheehan left the island on vacation immediately after Solando disappeared.

Movie vs Book

movie vs book

Comparison

Shutter Island provides an immersive psychological thriller, filled with suspense that captivates readers throughout. Its 2010 film adaptation offers a comparably thrilling experience while staying true to the original story. With its abundance of cryptic clues, unexpected twists, and disturbing revelations, the narrative prompts readers to question assumptions and closely examine each element.

One notable contrast between the two versions is the portrayal of the institute and the island itself, which appear more expansive and imposing in the film. While the book suggests a relatively small island, evoking a sense of claustrophobia for readers, the movie still captures the eerie ambiance established by Lehane’s vivid descriptions. The landscape and buildings in the film almost embody character-like qualities. Another significant difference lies in DiCaprio’s portrayal of Laeddis, evoking sympathy from viewers compared to the more malevolent depiction in the book.

The film’s conclusion is significantly more ambiguous compared to the book. While the overall storyline unfolds similarly, the film’s ending introduces uncertainty. As Laeddis converses with his doctor (revealed to be Chuck), he poses the question, “Would you rather live as a monster, or die as a hero?” This leaves the audience questioning whether he is feigning a relapse in order to seek the tranquility of ignorance that a lobotomy would provide.


Poster of Shutter Island, the 2010 movie by Martin Scorsese

Year

2010

Minutes

138

Movie Rate

8.20

Source: IMDb

Cover of Shutter Island, the 2003 book by Dennis Lehane

Year

2003

Pages

369

Book Rate

8.16

S: Goodreads

Book

Shutter Island

Country: USA

First published in: 2003

Length: 369 pages

Genre: Fiction

*Provided by Amazon

User polls & recommendations

Which is better?

Poster of Shutter Island, the 2010 movie by Martin Scorsese

Movie

0

%

11 VOTES

*You can vote only
once in this poll.

Cover of Shutter Island, the 2003 book by Dennis Lehane

Book

0

%

9 VOTES

*You can vote only
once in this poll.

movie

IS IT WORTH WATCHING?

Poster of Shutter Island, the 2010 movie by Martin Scorsese

WATCH

Yes

0

%

19% No

17 votes

4 votes

book

IS IT WORTH READING?

Cover of Shutter Island, the 2003 book by Dennis Lehane

READ

Yes

0

%

18% No

14 votes

3 votes

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LISTS AND GROUPS

Related Lists

FilmmakersMartin Scorsese

From Goodfellas to Gangs of New York, some of Scorsese’s most acclaimed films are based on books.