Filmography › P.J. Hogan

All the book-based movies and TV shows adapted by P.J. Hogan, ranked

P.J. Hogan, known for works such as Peter Pan or Confessions of a Shopaholic, has adapted several stories from the pages of books and comic books to the screen.
Below, we present a ranked list, from best to worst, of 3 P.J. Hogan movies and TV series based on existing source material. Revisit old favorites or discover hidden gems, whether books or film productions. We invite you to watch, read, and vote for any title, joining the debate of whether the book or the movie is better.
Peter Pan. Poster of the 2003 movie and cover of the 1906 book, Peter and Wendy
VS3
Peter and Wendy
J.M. Barrie, 1906
movie vs book
Peter Pan
P.J. Hogan, 2003

In 1904, in the nursery of the Darling household located in London, Wendy Darling tells stories of Peter Pan to her younger brothers John and Michael before their Aunt Millicent’s arrival. Jealous of Wendy’s presence, Tinker Bell tricks the Lost Boys into shooting Wendy with arrows as she is falling from the sky.

Peter Pan. Poster of the 2003 movie and cover of the book novelization
VS3
Peter Pan
Alice Alfonsi, 2003
movie vs book   [NOVELIZATION]
Peter Pan
P.J. Hogan, 2003

In 1904, in the nursery of the Darling household located in London, Wendy Darling tells stories of Peter Pan to her younger brothers John and Michael before their Aunt Millicent’s arrival. Jealous of Wendy’s presence, Tinker Bell tricks the Lost Boys into shooting Wendy with arrows as she is falling from the sky.

Confessions of a Shopaholic. Poster of the 2009 movie and cover of the 2000 book
VS3
Confessions of a Shopaholic
Sophie Kinsella, 2000
movie vs book
Confessions of a Shopaholic
P.J. Hogan, 2009

Rebecca Becky Bloomwood is a hardcore shopping addict who lives in New York City with her best friend Suze. However, the receptionist tells her there is an open position with the magazine Successful Saving, explaining that getting a job at Successful Saving could eventually lead to a position at Alette magazine.